Home › Forums › Core Seminars › East Asia: Origins to 1800, Spring 2018 › Session 1 readings (dube, 3/3 morning)
Hi Folks, Since we aren't giving you these far enough in advance, you're not expected to read and comment on them in advance. Bring them with you, however, (download to a laptop, tablet, or phone or print them out). After the session, you are expected to write at least one post discussing one or more of the readings or the ideas discussed in this session.
Below are five short magazine/newspaper articles concerning demographic and environmental trends in East Asia. Please note how cultures are changing to accommodate the realities of demographic change.
If you've got time Saturday evening, watch "Under the Dome," an astonishing documentary made by a Chinese journalist about the threat China's environmental crisis poses. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V5bHb3ljjbc Some call the video China's "Inconvenient Truth." Here's an article about the debate in China this video triggered. http://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-china-blog-31689232
My geography/demography preseentation is attached. You're welcome to use it with your students. Do not post it to the internet or otherwise share it.
In response to the controversy over the title of the sea between the Korean Peninsula and Japan, I looked for a map of East Asia in my textbook, Ways of the World by Robert Strayer. While the textbook is full of maps, most of them did not label this sea. I’ve attached one map I was able to found. As you can see, the textbook includes both labels: Sea of Japan/East Sea. Knowing this, I am going to ask students to study this map, and see if they notice anything interesting. From here, we can have a discussion about sourcing (Point of View and Purpose of documents) which is an important aspect of AP World History curriculum. I also plan to find a few articles about the Virginia textbook debate.
In Banyan's article, East Asia's "demographic crisis" indicates that East Asia will be facing some dilemnas if behaviors and attitudes continue to resist change. I agree with this and Ogburn's coined term 'cultural lag" describes how economic needs and changes in society continue to evolve in East Asia, while the cultural behaviors and attitudes are somewhat slower in their evolvement. This unequal gender dividend seems to happen in many cultures, but due to East Asia keeping their fertility rates at an all time low the impact is much greater for them. I find it interesting to learn that East Asian countries are so advanced in particular areas, yet so affected by their "cultural lag." The idea of women having to give up their career to have children or delaying marriage because of this seems so antiquated. It seems that cultural behaviors in terms of gender equity need to catch up in Esat Asian societies so that more women start seeing careers, marriage and child rearing as attractive choices. The pressure for change is on!
At the start of session one, we were asked to write the name of an East Asian country and a corresponding adjective. The country that I wrote was China and the adjective I chose was populous. In his demography and geography presention of East Asia, Professor Dube introduced a map of a globe with lights. As I viewed this map of the world, I thought about what a great visual this would be to teach students about East Asian economic and technological development and populations and its relation to the rest of the world and within the distinct East Asian countries. Instead of reading about this from a textbook, students can be exposed to this visual and be asked to draw conclusions, write questions and think critically about the kind of information a visual such as this suggests. By doing so, students can be guided to think and construct their own knowledge rather than simply reading this from a textbook. This is a great example of how visuals can enhance any lesson and get students to think about larger questions related to content and as an introduction to key ideas about East Asia. I appreciated how Professor Dube made strategic use of visuals and maps in this session and was inspired to use more such tools in my lesson plans. As the course develops, I hope to explore and think about how I can integrate these and how the use of these tools can reshape my lessons.
This would be an interesting activity for students to engage in that can lead to a discussion about history as a narrative and what information gets disseminated, perspective and why one point of view can be privileged over another. I found this example of the East Sea and Sea of Japan an interesting one that brings to light how history does not change but the story that gets told about that history seems to change. How history gets interpreted depends on the lense or perspective of the person presenting the facts and evaluating those facts. I found this to be one of the most thought provoking ideas presented in session one. This not only caused me to think about how history gets to be told and taught generally, but how I will teach history, what voices I will chose to include and to what purpose. Such a discussion would be an important one to have with our colleagues and with students so that they can become more critical in their evaluations of primary and secondary sources.
I, too, found Banyan's article to be very illuminating for me. Before reading the article, I understood some of the reasons contributing to the decreasing birth rate in East Asian countries and in Europe: women marrying later in life or refusing to marry altogether, women choosing to work rather than stay at home to raise a family, and so on. Upon reading this article, I learned that one of the most prevailing reasons why there is a decreasing birth rate in East Asian countries is the deeply held beliefs people have about women, their role in the family and how women are generally viewed. Although women in countries such as Japan, South Korea and China are educated and contributing to the economy by joining the work force, they are still viewed within the lense of tradition and so not enough social changes are taking place that support women who both want to work and raise a family. According to this article, the greatest barrier to increasing the birth rate of these countries is the resistance to shifts in attitudes about women. Since Asian countries are more traditional than for example, Germany, it is uncertain if these much needed shifts in perspective and attitudes will take place in time. I did not make this crucial connection before reading this article.
This article was quite interesting because it shed some light into where Japan's political power was held after world war two, while at the same time it somewhat explained how rice was seen as a symbol or some type of cultural artifact that must be kept in the traditional narative of Japanese history. Despite the fact that less people are consuming rice, and less rice is being grown it appears that the Abe government might be looking into changing traditional policies. A question that came to mind while reading this was how will traditional forms of political power change in the coming years in Japan? From a teacher pesrspective I see this topic as an opportunity of show casing two things to 8th grade students in U.S. History class. One, how are farmers in Japan and in America the same and different? Two, if Japan is a highly urbanized country where does its political power lie, in the cities or country side? In terms of rice production, this is an interesting question to focus when students are learning the plantaion system of the Southern Colonies. The article mentions how these days farmers can be part-time farmers since its a higly mechanized industry that requires less human hands. It made me wonder how many people had to work on the rice fields during colonial times, what could have been the number of slaves that had to work on an acre of land as opposed to how its work on today, say in California or Japan? Returning to political power, it made me think of the states that yield a lot of influence at the federal level, the "swing states," where populations are low but political capital is much more than in the more populous states. I could easily see an activity where I have some students sit in groups of four and others alone with three empty spaces, and figuiring out a way where decisions made in the classroom are heavily influences by two or three students that sit by themselves, now how does can this be used to shed some light into Japanese politics, I'm not sure, but an activity where students vote and move around would get them to think about how people organize society in places like Japan and how we in America organize our society and how that plays out in our every day lives.
I found this article quite interesting both as a European and as someone who is curious about how modern Asian and European societies will deal with their low fertility rates. The article places the fertility rate that countries need to have in order to stabilize their society and culture at 2.1%. That means, that for the culture, traditions, customs, etc of a socieity to perpetuate or remain somewhat similar, each woman should have two children. Any fertitility rate lower than that means the culture and customs of the country are more likely to change or be replaced by those of the new immigrants. I also found quite interesting how the article mentions how the European countries saw an increase in fertility rates after World War 2, which led to the big baby boom of the 1950's and 1960's to exemplify how this could be the case in Asia and how countries such as Japan, South Korea or China can see this problem resolved the same way it was resolved in Europe back in the day. However, it does not mention that the economic boom and industrialization that Europe saw during those decades after the war, due in its most part to the need of reconstructing those countries, doesn't compare to today's Asian socieities. European economies were not as global as Asian economies are these days. Those European countries created many jobs that were needed to rebuild the infrastructure and societies of those destroyed countries. In other words, most of the jobs created during the 1950's or 1960's were due to the increasing domestic consumption and deman. That's why I don't find this parallel to be completely comparable to modern Asian societies simply because a big amount of the jobs and products these countries generate depend on foreign consumption and demand.
I also found the way professor Dube used maps very interesting and helpful for my lessons. Instead of just providing students with a standard geographical map, it would be very interesting to provide them with a set of maps of the same region but that will trigger their curiosity and interest. Maybe using a light map as seen from space like the one used to show us the contrast between North Korea and South Korea. That in itself is more powerful and effective to help students understand the differences between both countries than any other map I've seen. Also, we could perhaps use a terrain or vegetation map to help them better understand the challenges a specific region has to address when it comes to the environment, war, infrastructure, etc. I agree with you, I think that by presenting student with sets of maps and "guide them to think and construct their own knowledge" we can see an increase in student curiosity and interest.
After reading the article on China’s environmental tipping point, I was pleased, intrigued, yet still worried about China’s environmental future.
I applaud Ma Jun and other environmentalists for bringing awareness to China's environmental crisis through new laws, documentaries and apps. However, as China has grown economically, more people in China see the immediate benefits of becoming financially stable/prosperous and turn a blind eye to the side effect of China’s economic growth—environmental depletion. And, as the article states, “When you have a situation where the laws are there but the enforcement is not quite there, then you’re basically rewarding those who cut corners and hurting those who try to be responsible.”
So, it’s great that people are starting to notice and fight on behalf of the environment but, I’m curious to see if and how people will give up their greed towards money to help save the environment. After all, what is the point in being wealthy if there is no safe place to live?
[Clearly this isn’t a China only issue, but I’m curious to see how this movement and the Blue Map app will impact China and its citizens.]
Both China's government and businesses are both invested in economic growth and development and this is generally viewed as a positive development. This article, however, brings to light the cost of that economic growth and development and its dire consequences on water health, the health of the environment and on people's health with cancer on the rise. The consequences of development can be tragic and they paint a gloomy picture. But the article points to a hopeful development; that is, that people can organize and actively work to expose pollution and cause the government to regulate violators. Although the government and companies in China cannot regulate themselves or each other, the common citizen can. This is a powerful message to teach students. This article can be used in lessons in environmental justice to both point out the negative effects of economic growth and develpment and to show students that activism can work to bring about positive change.
I am so sad when I think and talk about this topic nowadays- “ China’s environmental problems”.
It is true. According to the article “China has reached its environmental tipping point” in China one-fifth of farmland is too polluted to grow crops, nearly 60% of ground water is unfit for human use, and air pollutions is 20 times the recommended safe levels.
The human cost of this damage had been devastating: rice contaminated with heavy metals , more than 450 so-called “cancer villages”, choking levels of air pollution causing underweight babies, rising level of lung cancer and a decline in male fertility. Air pollutions causes 4,400 deaths in China every single day.
Although China’s leadership has promised a “war on pollution” to regain public trust, it is the decisions of local government officials. According to Ma that it’s the local environmental officials that are in charge of enforcement, but they are subordinate to local government. Their heads are appointed by local government. Those who want to stick to the laws could be replaced. This is the very harsh reality. It won’t be easy to change it Ma said.
In a rare display of danger, China’s rising middle class took to the Chinese social media website “Wechat”, demanding the Government take action and protect the children of China. They said the Government’s “War on pollution”, now it is the third year, has not delivered results. A petition asking the government to install air filtration systems in schools gathered nearly half a million views and more than 2.700 comments before it was shut down. Many of my friends and relatives still live in China. I pray and hope that they could have clean air to breath and clean water to drink again in the near future.
Sources: The world post/ Ma Jun: China has reached its environmental tipping point/ ABC news.
Much of Asia has the problem that people have low fertility and an upside-down family structure. Three -quarters of all the people in countries with exceptionally low Fertility live in East and south-East Asia. Prosperous Japan, South Korea and Taiwan have fertility rates of 1.4 or below.
Demographers say socioeconomic changes are the fundamental reasons for low Fertility rates and smaller families according to the article. Simply setting a population policy that encourages couples to reproduce won’t help much. “It is not the government’s job to pay people or encourage people to have more children” said Stuart Basten, associate professor of social policy at the University of Oxford. “ But it is the government’s job to make society a better place and to help people in their aspirations to …achieve what they want to achieve. In that way, fertility rates would probably go up” said Dr. Basten. I strongly agree what Dr. Basten said. Although we do not have any policy which encourage people to have babies, we could have a lot of policies about childcare, maternity leave, and a national health system which supports older people …There could be more a supportive atmosphere towards childbearing.
Sources: Article-Asia’s new family values/ US.News
What professor Dube brought up was a good point on the power of labels and how we label things. As a history teacher working in a public school it is easy to forget the power of labels, especially when trying to build the skills that students need to take various state assessments that check for understanding of writing, listening, reading and speaking level. However, when I returned to the classroom, I took this idea and let my students think about the types of images we get when we think of different music genres and the people we associate with them. In this case building on Black History month I let my students watch a short documentary on the history of rock music and the associations we make when we think of rock. During the video the same topic of labeling is brought up and how much power that evokes. Needless to say the students learned a little bit more on the history of rock and its pioneers.
Now, bringing it back to what was discussed in the seminar. I can recall how labels have power, and how history and what is written about regions also has a form of power. Hence when China decided to have its forum on Goguryeo and applied for some sites within its borders to become a UNESCO World Heritage it created some outrage and controversy. So, we are left with some loose ideas of what happened in these regions and we can gather some understanding of their past, but when it comes to writing history and whose history it encompasses then there is reason for alarm. This shows not only the divergent views that countries in East Asia have of their respective histories, but also how with enough money and power countries can counter how history is written, hence the incidents happening in the US. Here the politics of how we name parts of East Asia are also coming up, and in a fascinating manner, from a plaque that was put up in Culver City a few decades ago to the innocent but controversial labeling of a time line in a museum, which led to simply removing the sign. I definitively want my students to carry with them a sense that everything that they read must be judged with a grain of salt, but at the same time they too must be willing to express their critical thoughts through writing, but ultimately they understand as well as I that history is fluid and can be changed by the whims of those in power or those beginning to have access to power.