Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 17 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #7108
    cgao
    Spectator

    REQUIRED

    Readings

    Videos

    4a. Generations 

    For this lecture, there's a point where we pause so that you can read two sections of this attached file "24 Filial Piety Exemplars"

     

     

    4b. Environmental Degradation

    The second lecture for week 4 focuses on China's serious environmental challenges.

     

     

    OPTIONAL 

     

    #41021
    Judy Schechter
    Spectator

    Here is the Swedish website I mentioned in tonight's chat.  Dollar Street allows you to look at how people all around the world live on different incomes.  There is a lot of rich visual information to be mined here, great for younger students, ELLs, and other students who struggle with literacy.  Be sure to click on the "visit this home" option.

    https://www.gapminder.org/dollar-street/matrix

     

     

    #41031
    Chris Hertzog
    Spectator

    I will definitely be using this article, or at least the charts comparing the 1980s generation compared to the post 1980s generations see themselves, the world and life.  This is a terrific article to have students look at the generational diferences in China from the pre 80s to the post 80s and then compare what has happened in the same generations in the United States and/or what has happened in Europe during the same time period.

    Those categories are eerily universally similar in nature to what was going on in the States and Western Europe in that time period.  Perhaps the numbers are a bit different, but those questions and categories are definitely applicable to all three regions.  Relations to friends, influence of Japanese Anime, usage of the internet, fastfood eating habits, attention to appearance and cooperation with others levels are all things that can be investigated not only in China during the same time period but also in the U.S. and Europe.

    However, in addtion to all of that, kids today would probably have even more to say on those same attitudes.  How does this current generation here in the California see these topics?  And how do the students today see these numbers in comparison to how they live now.  I think this would be a great introduction or attention grabber to start a period of class or discussion.

    #41053
    Brett Kier
    Spectator

    How the environmental crisis facing China is addressed by its people and its leadership in many ways has been an example for the US to follow. However, the following presuppositions about the environmental crisis facing China (and the world) need to be addressed by teachers at some point, and dealt with in a serious way. In particular, the following questions need to be discussed by students:

    1. Why, if temperature increases drive increases in carbon dioxide, does the media discourse on the issue of sustainability pretend the opposite is true (id est, X -> Y, rather than Y -> X)? See the following documentary for an outline of these well documented scientific observations.
    2. Why does the discussion of environmental sustainability (and alternative sources of energy) completely ignore vast swaths of scientific knowledge that could improve the quality of the air and water globally?
    3. Why do we constantly conflate carbon dioxide with pollution, when they are fact separate but correlated phenomenon?

    There is a serious issue concerning intellectual honesty on our part when we engage in the framing of false dichotomies for students, ex gratia, if it is not solar, electric, or wind powered, it has no place in a technologically advanced society – or that those are the only solutions available to us, which if pursued too quickly will upend the global economy.  Students should be given an opportunity to understand that those in power will always seek to create scarcity (real or imagined), in order to maintain the status quo. With all the talk of saving the planet by not having children or riding bikes instead of driving cars, we make no mention of plummeting birth rates worldwide, or the real danger that bioengineering (cloud seeding, et cetera) poses to the environment. Additionally, major inefficiencies within the free market need to be highlighted to students regarding the environmental movement and sustainability generally. Topics for consideration include:

    Planned Obsolescence – see the documentary The Lightbulb Conspiracy (good for econ classes as well)

    Hydrogen Fuel Technology (Brown’s Gas, HHO) – machinery that is currently in existence that runs on water (technology that can be used to create vehicles that run on water); this technology is seeing wider use in China than in the US

    GEET Fuel Processors – retrofitted to existing gas powered motors, a technology that can nearly eliminate particulate matter (pollution) release from internal combustion engines (built in the 1980s); which can also be used in waste disposal plants to the same level of effectiveness

    Electro-magnetic motors – shown in the laboratory to be as much as 300% efficient (see De Palma’s N-Machine), and pollution free

    #41056
    Brett Kier
    Spectator

    This would be a good entry point for a multicultural analysis of attitudes across Asia and the West broadly, comparing and contrasting opinion polls on things like desire for children, marriage, higher education aspirations, et cetera. Perhaps a fishbowl activity might be effective as a warmup using this data.

    #41057
    Margaret Siryj
    Spectator

    The Evans' Article from 2010, published in "China Quarterly" argues that culture and its "socially  constituted articulations" including idioms and symbols are ever-evolving and changing.  Many urban young women and their younger city friends are being molded by China's cityscape and ways of life.  These women and their mothers do not necessarily agree and experience generational differences.  Evans suggest that similar to Western ways and ideals, mothers and their daughters have different views when it comes to intimacy.  Intimacy is a private emotion and interpersonal ethics have not been part of the dialogue between mothers and their female offspring.  This would be an interesting classroom discussion for my seniors, my sophomores could not handle it, but my 12th graders would be open to share if interpersonal ethics is a topic that is discussed in their home, or is it considered "off limits"?

    #41058
    Margaret Siryj
    Spectator

    Dr. Dube's Mini Lecture regarding environmental China was quite interesting and surprising on several fronts.  Wen Jiabao was certainly concerned about China's Economic Growth as he stated it was "unsteady, unbalanced, uncoordinated, and unsustainable".  However, fast forward to 2017 and the graphs were noticed as great improvements on the part of the Chinese.  In 2007, about 10 years ago, roughly 1000 Chinese people died prematurely due to air pollution, and in 2016 that number was quadrupled.  But the surprising part came with the pie graphs featured in the lecture.  Hydropower, wind, and solar panel production which is the largest clearly demonstrates that China is making tremendous strides and is highly contributing positively to the overall decrease in air polution.

    My World History students can continue to research China and report the most current information available for proactive attempts and celebrations for air pollution reduction.  I think my students will be just as surprised as I was seeing the pie graphs with comparisons for China and the US.

    #41062
    Paul Phillips
    Spectator

    Thanks Judy,

    I've used the animated charts in Gapminder Tools, as a discussion starter to examine China's relative standard of living (life expectancy and income per capita) over the 19th and 20th centuries. Students see China's dramatic rise and are challenged to identify events that have impacted the standard of living (globally or locally)

    https://www.gapminder.org/tools/?from=world#$chart-type=bubbles

    #41063
    Paul Phillips
    Spectator

    I was interested to read about changing attitudes and behavior resulting from the shift towards a much more individualized Chinese society. Having never lived in a society that was founded on collective action and joint responsibility, I've always taken individualization for granted. 

    The three articles about evolving expectations for mother/daughter relationships, changes to courtship and perceptions of young rural Chinese, revealed how individual needs are being recognized and respected, while responsibility to family obligations remains a very powerful collectivization force. We see that, while arranged marriages are no longer practiced, the influence of the family remains extremley strong when chosing a marriage partner based on introduction or free choice. The increased mobility and economic independence of younger Chinese has blended with Confucian filial piety to create a unique mixture of modern and traditional family values, interactions and decision making.

    I was also surprised to see in the "Sub Cultures of China Youth" video that the average age for marriage appears to be lowering rather than increasing, as would be expected in an inceasingly affluent and developed society. The video did not provide an explanation for this - I can only assume that the gender imbalance resulting from the one child policy may have created a sense of urgency amongst young men who fear not being able to find a mate.

     

    #41064

    According to the article, “The Ministry of Education has sharpened the distinctions that divide the best schools from the very good, the good, and the mediocre, and it has designated a small number of elite schools, headed by Tsinghua (Qinghua) and Peking (Beijing) universities, to receive the level of funding that will enable them to achieve world-class status.” What I would like to know is aside from test scores, what are the criteria used to decide who gains entrée into each school? Is there a quota system of some sort based on geography ethnicity?  Does political affiliation enter the equation? in Dr. Dube's video, we can also see the dramatic rise in the number of institutions of higher education since 1984, approximately 1000, to now over 2,500 in 2014. China sees the link between education and economic prosperity. Yet there is also that pull to the west as well as record numbers of Chinese have left to study abroad, primarily the United States. What I found interesting was the recent news in the United States about the “scandal” that was exposed at several elite colleges. That there is a link between the ringleader and a college counseling firm in China came as a surprise to me, but then again, should it have? Who are these Chinese that solicit the services of college counseling firms for US schools?

    https://www.edsurge.com/news/2019-03-15-ringleader-of-admissions-scam-also-ran-a-college-counseling-firm-for-families-in-china

     

     

     

    #41065
    Judy Schechter
    Spectator

    I found this week’s readings pretty dispiriting, especially with regard to women’s roles in society and the severe threat posed by toxic soil.  I also have a number of follow-up questions regarding the readings.

    China, like the U.S., still suffers from entrenched adherence to gender stereotypes and expectations.  The “Playing With the Old Blood Rules” article states that “many Chinese parents are now even reconsidering their long-held prejudice for sons, on the new assumption that daughters are more likely to grow into loyal caregivers.”  Based on the other readings alone, I find this sentiment hard to believe--to wit the Chinese slang term for girls being “thin padded jackets.”

    From the “Gender of Communication” article, it seems, too, that women’s work is never done.  As is frequently the case in the U.S., Chinese working mothers are are expected to run their households largely on their own.  Elderly grandmas and aunties are also expected to take on these kinds of responsibilities. And the idea of adopting an adult female daughter for caregiving and companionship? Nice in the abstract, but where are the men???

    With all the problems posed by an aging population and the reluctance of young people to shoulder the responsibility of caretaking, has the government considered the idea of changing its apparent masculine ideal to accommodate for the need for more support for the elderly?  Could the concept of filial piety be used to encourage more men to do or share this important work with their female counterparts? And where are Chinese feminists with respect to these issues? Clay, do you have any readings for us on this subject?

    It’s no surprise to me, then, that many Chinese young people and couples are opting not to have children.  It was also interesting to read that a survey found that a minority of young people wanted to join the party because they believed in communism.  As noted in the ”Contemporary Chinese Youth and the State” article, “the post-1980’s generation has ensured that their public lives are placed in service to their private ambitions.”  Clearly, party membership has increasingly become an economic necessity for upwardly-mobile young Chinese adults, indeed, a necessary investment for the future.

    Question:  what are the criteria for party membership?  Are some people invited to join? What are the benefits of being a party member?  And what are the effects of not being a party member?

    Regarding the materials on toxic soil, this was a sobering read indeed.  I’m glad that the article talked about how different branches of the Chinese government have been addressing this issue.  I’m teaching civics and government next year and can see myself comparing the how the Love Canal problem was addressed on the local, regional, and federal levels here to the Chinese responses to toxic soil as described in the article.  I wish Mr. Tang good luck. It blows me away that China’s contaminated soil is roughly equivalent to the amount of arable soil in Mexico. Yikes.

     
    #41066
    Judy Schechter
    Spectator

    Glad you could use it!

    #41067
    Judy Schechter
    Spectator

    Article about Muslim detention camps in Xinjiang from the NY Times.  Related articles (not posted here) talk about the tepid response from much of the international Muslim community to the camps based on trade and foreign investment concerns.

    https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/12/world/asia/china-xinjiang.html

     

    #41068
    Chris Hertzog
    Spectator

    The material from this week is really terrific as Margaret states in her post above.  The pollution, deaths, ground water pollution and the air quality is really, really unbelievable.  They of course have come an incredible distance when it has come to industrialization and growth, but at such a human cost and environmental cost. 

    And it at least appears that the Chinese system or the government has decided to clean up and so it goes.  It will be facinating to watch to see if they really can shift the direction to economic and industrial growth while at the same time moving to hydropower and solar.  It sure seems if anyone can make that change, it would be China in the phase they are in.  Certainly, they cannot sustain the growth they are having with the pollution that is killing so many people.

    Great articles for this topic this week to use in class.  Here also is an NPR article I mentioned last week on electric cars.

    https://www.npr.org/2019/03/06/700873537/the-increasing-demand-for-electric-cars

    #41069
    Chris Hertzog
    Spectator

    Goths on Sina Weibo

    https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-47615966

    Here is the article from the BBC on the insta-goth movement over a woman asked to leave a train due to her makeup. 

    Definitely something to grab teens in our culture on the power and speed of social media.  Certainly this could be a great way to look at social media intensity in both a closed country like China vs a more open country like the U.S. in regards to access and use of social media.

    What is also interesting or a curiosity for our students could be at looking at something like the Goth movement and asking where it came from in China or is it something coming from outside China.  Is it a Japanese or American cultural push or movement, or is it a latent or delayed connection to the 80s or a retro movement going on?

    I suspect my students would have a better idea on how to answer these questions than I do!

     

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 17 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.