Home › Forums › Core Seminars › Modern East Asia, Fall 2020 › Session 1 (9/23) - Demography & Geography
Speaker: Clayton Dube, USC
For the first session, there are two video lectures. The first is on East Asian Geography and Demography. The second is on East Asia in 1800.
For each session, please watch the video lectures and complete the required readings. Please post your thoughts about the content or how you might introduce it to your students in the forum. Please do this BEFORE the Wednesday and Saturday discuss sessions.
East Asian Geography and Demography
Required readings for geography and demography (pdfs below):
Asia's demographic crisis
Can machines solve the labor shortage?
Women discuss cultural heritage in Japan
Korean-Japanese map dispute spills over into US schools
Optional:
Coal and the Korean peninsula
China's environmental crisis
East Asia in 1800
Required readings for the East Asia in 1800 lesson:
Emperor Qianlong to King George III (online at: https://china.usc.edu/emperor-qianlong-letter-george-iii-1793)
Heshen - charges against him and an inventory of his riches
Ebrey, anti-opium placards in Guangzhou
Aizawa Seishisai, Dealing with barbarians
Daily Life in Edo (scan)
Optional (to browse):
Edo Art in Japan (complete exhibition catalog from the National Gallery of Art), includes many street scenes, chapters devoted to work, to samurai, to entertainment, and more: https://www.nga.gov/content/dam/ngaweb/research/publications/pdfs/edo-art-in-japan.pdf
The presentations -- pdf copies of the presentations are attached below. Please feel free to use them with your students. Please don't otherwise share them.
As Clayton mentioned, we think of many of the areas in East Asia as a place where water is a dominant resource due to the climate there. I was surprsied to learn that this was not the case. When I was a 4th grade teacher, we disussed a water scarcity issue in the 1800s in California when the population in San Francisco drastically increased from the Gold Rush. Now that I am an art teacher, I was inspired to think of a global project, being that this is a global dilemna. I recently learned of a new organziation called Waves for Water that strives to provide clean water to areas in the world that lack it. After researching, I found that East Asia is on their list of places they reach out to. In this research, I saw that they have raised very little money towards their goal for East Asia. This spoke to me. This is a new organization; therefore, the public eye needs to be informed of the situation and this organization. Creating awareness at my school would be a start. I could provide an opportunity for the students to create a poster for our school, not only to raise awareness of the water scarcity, but also to raise much needed funds for this organization. A global project like this would provide students with an opportunity to take action for East Asia, aswell as, valuable knowledge about different parts of the world.
I am teaching Geography as an elective teacher for all grades in middle school. Two of the five themes of geography are movement and human-environment interaction. This deals with one of the six essential elements Environment and Society and this includes the geography standard 16. The distribution and meaning of resources. Students can learn about Water on Earth and this includes Water Problems. This is about the water problems and the lack of fresh-water. Students can compare and contrast water shortage problems from Asia and the United States. An example that comes to mind is Flint, Michigan water crisis. Newsela has different articles that students can read that talk about Flint, Michigan. They can read about “Stories from around the world showcase the problem of water inequality” by National Geographic Society, adapted by Newsela staff. This article is about poor water quality.
Aging Population: Ask students what is going to happen to society who has an aging society. Who is going to take care of the older population? Challenges will deal with the government and financially. Example can be used are Japan and South Korea. For example, the article that we had to read for the Two Koreas seminar had examples of the aging population was suffering with Covid-19. (https://china.usc.edu/sites/default/files/Gibson%2C%20South%20Korea%E2%80%99s%20Elderly%20Face%20Unique%20Challenges%20From%20COVID-19.pdf). Have students come up with solutions that can help society’s with aging population. The article of Asia’s demographic Crisis talks about Asia’s low fertility rate. It goes on to compare how in the 20th century Europe had low fertility rate too and it gives solutions that can help Asia with low fertility rate. The document goes on to say that Asian men will have to be more supportive husband and father if they want to get married because women are dissatisfied with their options. They cannot be too big on keeping their gender roles. Yoshiaki Nohara’s article gives a solution that can be used in society to combat a problem with aging population, which is labor shortage. The article states how Japan is using robots in factories so that they can do the hard lifting. This article can also be used for students to read and for us to have a class discussion.
Household expenditure: Students can compare and contrast what each country spends their money on compared in the pie chart. We can have a discussion about why the United States housing % is so high compared to the Asian countries. Students can compare the housing prices between different states, for example, California and Texas or so.
Living in Southern California, we can relate to China and Korea in terms of water resources and scarcity. I often have my students read articles about current events to helps with reading comprehension. This information would promote a nice class discussion on what we can do to conserve water and less polluted. California was in a drought for a long time and with record heat temperatures, fires, and not much rainfall, water isn't something to take for granted here. Our students can use less water by turning off the faucet when brushing their teeth, taking shorter showers, swimming in the ocean to cool off rather than running a sprinkler for hours, etc. They can also help out by using reusable water bottles rather than plastic one-use ones that often aren't recycled, throwing out their trash, and using more reusable items. Yesterday, I ran along the Los Angeles "river" and it is practically gone in the area where I was. This is a scary thought because we need clean water to live and stay healthy. Water pollution is a big problem, but also, the lecture talked about reservoirs having silt build up and extreme flooding which all put a strain on our water supplies. North and South Korea are having fights over the water in a dam and thus water is being misused. Water pipes in LA have burst as well. Fresh water should not be taken for granted and changes need to be made world-wide. I am eager to bring this question up with my students this week.
An aging society, like that of which we see in Japan, is when a society is made up of more older people than younger. At an elementary level, they may not initially see the negative impact this can have on a society. Providing this awareess in an academic discussion can lead to a dynamic realization. As an art teacher, it would use this an opportunity to expose them to artists such as Yayoi Kusama and Takashi Murakami. Bringing up their age difference, and then examining the motivations for some of their pieces can lead to a discussion about how history and culture is recorded through art. For example, Kusama's Walking Piece, suggests the traditional roles of a women in the Japanese culture. Discussions around the idea that older and younger artists are visual historians could lead to a deeper understanding of the impacts an aging society can have on a culture.
The charts were very interesting to compare. I predicted that housing and food was the largest across the world. I connected with the idea that as a non-homeowner American, this trend impacts a society, and how that may vary quite differntly in other countries. The large percentage towards transportation was surprising, especially knowing that transportation varies from country to country. I would use these charts to focus on the entertainment and culture portion of the charts. Upper grade standards asks students to research and summarize artists and how they affected their time period or culture. Students can choose an East Asian artist, or one from their own culture, and have students reflect upon the impacts of the arts in that culture.
The statistics shared about the Industrial Revolution suggest to me that where there is significantly high population in one area, there comes a significant need for an increase in education and development. High population inevitably results in problems that need solutions (transportation, supply and demand, shelter, etc). Research needs to occur to solve these problems; therefore, I would assume that a rise in those getting a higher education would be needed. Inventions/solutions would then take place, revlutionizing the way a society functions.
One of the topics we are discussing in 1st grade Social Studies is the function of government. What does a government do? How do (or should) governments serve their communities? We've discussed the concept of scarcity in the context of money, specifically that governments don't have enough money to do everything they want to do, so there are usually votes, meetings, committees, etc. to make decisions about how to use what they have. We can extend this thinking to water scarcity, which is certainly something that affects us in Southern California. Especially when students are growing up in urban areas like Los Angeles, they do not necessarily think about the water that comes out of their faucets. Where does it come from? Who decides how it is distributed? This can get students thinking about functions of government they may not have considered. It also connects to our first unit in ELA, Community Helpers. What are some ways we can make a difference in our community? Making sure you are conserving water, or even advocating for water conservation among your family and friends, is one way to start.
Post 2:
The Qing dynasty’s attitude toward the British is firm. The emperor told the British King that it didn’t make sense for an envoy to be placed in the his courts to control trade with China and the king’s request was denied. I found it very interesting that the Chinese emperor refers to Europeans nations as barbarians. This is similar to what Europeans call people from the lands they colonized. He does explain why the request of King George III (Britain) was denied. Chinese Emperor Quianlong does state that there is no benefit to allowing a British envoy to remain in his courts because their civilization is different to the British. The emperor was very firm with his response to the King and he does tell him to make good decisions.
Both Japan and China limited access foreigners had in their country. Advantages Japan and China had with limiting access was that they could limit what came into their country. If they would have allowed the Europeans free reign they could have influenced the Asian population. Disadvantages could be that both Asian countries went through the Industrial Revolution much later than Europeans and Americans. Class discussion as to why Japan and China didn’t want to give more access to Europe. Predict what they think is going to happen between China and Europe or Japan and Europe. Then we can read Ebrey’s “Anti-Opium Placards in Guangzhu.pdf” that allows the reader to know about the Opium War between China and Great Britain. Students can see the reaction of the citizens of Guangzhou and how they planned to react against the barbarians. The barbarians was anyone that would go to the city. Students can compare this article to another topic they have learned about. For example, students can answer “What restrictions was the government placing on the citizens? What actions were the citizens planning on taking or took? Why do you believe citizens reacted like this? How would you react if you were living in Guangzhou during this time period? “ Aizawa Seishisai article, “Dealing with barbarians” can be used and given to students to read and answer the questions (DBQ) about Japan’s view on the barbarians.
My class is doing a lot of learning revolving around our community, which is certainly different to teach when we cannot even be together physically as a school or class community. One thing we have talked about is how people in our community have different types of families. I have multiple students who are living with their grandparents right now, or who like to tell me about their grandparents living in other countries. I could easily tie in family structures in other cultures, including East Asian cultures, and how it is traditionally more common for grandparents to live with their children than it is in the U.S. We are also starting to think about how life is different in various places and time periods. For example, we look at how school or transportation can vary depending on where or when you're living. Having an aging population can affect many aspects of daily life - students might be interested in Japan's embrace of robotics to supplement the work force, for example.
One of the first grade Social Studies standards is "understand basic economic concepts and the role of individual choice in a free-market economy." These charts demonstrate perfectly how those choices can vary from country to country. Related to the money scarcity discussion we had previously, we can review how people and governments need to choose how best to spend their money when there are more choices than they can afford. Students might be surprised to learn that in countries like China, people spend a much bigger part of their income on food. We can talk about why that might be (e.g. living in California, we have easy access to a lot of different produce items, while in other parts of the world, those items need to be shipped in). We can talk about how different countries have different economic strengths - for example, some students know that many tech items and video game franchises come from Japan. We can also look at the amount of farm land available in different countries, which connects to the standard in which students describe how the physical environment affects the way people live.
In 3rd grade our first Social Studies unit covers the continents, oceans, equator, prime meridian and the hemispheres. Going over the diffrerent Asian countries and placing them in the appropriate hemispheres would help my students establish their geographical bearings of Asia, while also giving them an insight into how different parts of countries have varying weather patterns and temperatures (this also would tie in with our Science weather unit.)
In addition to learning about continents and countries, we also talk about smaller scale cities, towns, and states in our first Social Studies unit. This would be really fun to discuss how Clay mentioned both Korean countries and Japan individually have smaller populations than the state of California. I think my students would really be amazed by that fact! When discussing California cities, we spent a lesson discussing the Golden Gate Bridge and how it is an iconic landmark to San Francisco. It would be a great tie in to the Chinese civil engineering of The Great Wall to do a Venn Diagram of how they are similar, yet also, very different. Students would be given the opportunity to really learn about their home state of California and realize that across the Pacific Ocean are numerous countries whom we have a lot in common with geographically.
In our Science lesson last week we were planting albino corn seeds when one of my students asked, "How do I know if it needs more water?" Such an innocent question, but it led to a powerful conversation about water management and the recurring drought in Los Angeles. We discussed how if people are wasteful with water faucets, long showers, etc. it isn't good for the enivornment. This was followed by if we don't have enough clean water, we wouldn't be able to hydrate our bodies, hydrate plants and other organisms, or be able to live for very long because we all need water to survive. When we brought the conversation back to our Science lesson we decided to water one of the corn seeds once every 2 days vs. every other day to see if we notice a difference. My students are really into this experiment and I think this information could be a great tie in to the lesson.
With an aging society, like in Japan, it is important to point out to our students why this is important. Yes, they're living a longer life; however, when the chart came up on the nursing home needs and intrafamily murders I was a little caught off guard...and I'm an adult. For me to explain this to 3rd graders, I would tie it in with our ELA Benchmark unit titled "Communities Then and Now." It's a great transition to discuss how places have changed and adapted over the years both geographically and as a society. The populations in a majority of places have only increased - so bringing in the high population statistics for 65+ year olds from Asian countries compared to those in the United States would be a fun activity. This could be done with a T Chat or a variety of thinking maps.
When the chart popped up and Clay stated, "China and India had over half of Global GDP' I wasn't surprised. In the 1800's the United States was still a fairly young country trying to gain its bearings. With these statistics being from the middle of the Industrial Revolution, it doesn't shock me at all that China began creating factories to build and execute anything and everything they could. When you have populations that massive, you need to create jobs and forms of income for people to be able to support themselves. It's a double whammy that they were able to not only use their population for the greater good, but also expand their mark on the world with the amount of goods being created/delivered.