Home › Forums › Core Seminars › East Asia Origins to 1800, Spring 2022 › session 7, may 9 on religions
We will focus on Buddhism in these two lectures and readings, but we'll also discuss other religious traditions in East Asia. These include a variety of local faiths,Shamanism and Shintoism.
Lori Meeks, USC
Required readings, please skim them:
Mitchell-Jacoby, "Chinese Experiences of Buddhism"
Mitchell-Jacoby, "Korean Experiences of Buddhism"
Mitchell-Jacoby, "Japanese Experiences of Buddhism"
Optional resources:
The UNESCO Courier, June 1956 - "Twenty-five Centuries of Buddhist Art and Culture"
Bonus lecture:
There are many beautiful images, paintings, sculptures, and buildings dedicated to Buddhism. I think that one way to approach Buddhism in a secondary art class would be to start off with a KWL Chart for the students. Have them first fill out what they Know/ or think they Know about Buddhism, then also fill out the What I want to Know portion after a small class discussion of what they think they know. I think that the students would be interested in learning about a different world religion that does have historic roots here in Los Angeles, as we have a lot of temples. After learning about Buddhism the students would complete the What I Learned portion of the KWL Chart. This could be a start to a Zentangle project where students learn the basics of what is Zen and how to create patterns in a meditative practice. There is also a cute TEDEd video that explains some of the principles of Zen Buddhism https://youtu.be/9p5Oi4wPVVo
[clay dube here - i logged in using a test ID to test some things about the system]
Jennifer - thanks for these great ideas. I think other possibilities include exploring how representations of the Buddha vary, including how the Alexander the Greek invasion may have influenced facial features. See this: https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/arts/classics/research/undergrads/jivan_kandola_completed_poster_urss.pdf
There is also a change in an important bodhisattva, Avalokiteśvara, as the faith and representations traveled to East Asia. Here's a book on the subject:
https://cup.columbia.edu/book/becoming-guanyin/9780231548731 A short blog entry by the author: https://cupblog.org/2020/03/03/yuhang-li-on-becoming-guanyin/ And a 10 minute video by the author: https://eastasianarthistory.org/2020/08/10/becoming-guanyin/
The Met has a short comparison of the Virgin Mary and Guanyin as figures of compassion. https://www.metmuseum.org/perspectives/articles/2021/5/virgin-mary-guanyin
The Univ. of Washington web companion to the Ebrey text has images and description of Guanyin.
I love seeing the connections in these lectures between East Asia and India, and the focus on where the forms of Buddhism connect and where they diverge. Students often make vast generalizations about the religions practiced in each area and why, and get very confused about the connectivity between China and India.
I'm glad the first article mentioned the Ellora Caves. The Ellora Caves in are an important piece of history to share - with santuraries built to Buddhism, Hinduism, and Jainism from A.D. 600 to 1000. It shwocases an ancient multiculturalism that is often not talked about.
https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/243/
Given how divisive a lot of these topics of religion and co-existence can be today, I like the idea of showing and sharing this history of peaceful co-existence with students.
I know I always make the comparisons but that is what we typically do in AP World. Buddhism is a great example to look at religious syncretism and how it shifts to fit the population like Zen Buddhism. That is usually a conversation we have in my class about the warrior culture in Japan and Buddhism also being prevalent. I always like to look at how the Buddha is depicted in different cultures and how temples are structured. We also discuss the blending of Shintoism and Buddhism. I know today we can see this in Japan with places like the Asakusa temple complex in Tokyo which has both a Buddhist temple but also a Shinto shrine. Professor Dube pointed out that blending in our discussion with some people adhering to Shinto rituals sometimes in their life but Buddhist at other times.
In our discussion I thought it was interesting in our discussion about ‘unclean’ professions and the difference with China about if a son is born to a prostitute that the son is still an heir. I think that is an interesting comparison to make with the adopted children as heirs in Japan but also how very stuck to a ‘blood line’ Europeans are. Going back to our discussion on Korea, that emphasis on status over gender could kind of fit in that conversation.
One question I do have that might not fit this time period… Buddhism and transgender? There was a book I read that focused on transgender and part of it was set in Thailand, where it kind of explained because of the nature of the soul in Buddhism there isn’t technically a gender for the soul. Is that a thing? It wasn’t a historic book. When students ask me about this I know there are some Indigenous American societies where transgender people were ‘of two spirits’. How do these non-western religions deal with that concept.
I have not really focused on Islam in China before when I taught 7th grade history. I found a good video that would help students connect history content with the real world.
Video: https://ca.pbslearningmedia.org/resource/islam-china-story-of-china/islam-china-story-of-china/
Standard: WH.7.2.4 Discuss the expansion of Muslim rule through military conquests and treaties, emphasizing the cultural blending within Muslim civilization and the spread and acceptance of Islam and the Arabic language
I am wondering how else I can teach about the history of religions & languages through a focus on specific populations and everyday practices/routines.
Betsy - delighted that you're interested in teaching about Islam in China as part of your courses. We've had workshops on just that topic since about 2004. That was before we put our teacher programs online. But we had one program aimed at teachers in 2020 that you can watch. It features my friend Dru Gladney, a friend of mine who was killed in a tragic accident two months ago. It also features a specialist in Uyghur music and a Venice High School vice principal who is from Xinjiang. Check it out: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pcl3VdqmWgk&list=PLZoSvm2n7tkcqaMPK7o7JSI53DViMc_Mf This program focused on Xinjiang and the Uyghurs, but earlier presentations focused on the religion more generally and looked at different Muslim groups within China (e.g., Hui, Kazakhs). We can list some of our speakers and the readings they suggested.
Here is a contemporary article from the NYTimes that digs into tattoos in Japan a little more, including indigenous roots, organized crime links, and the influence that westernization had in banning tattoos, and now in making them mainstream. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/04/23/world/asia/japan-tattoo.html
After our lecture on Monday, I spoke with a colleague of mine in Tokyo. She said that in 2019, Tokyo hosted a massive international Rugby tournament. As you can imagine, many of the players sported many tattoos. Many onsens allowed them admission- which caused an outrage from tattooed Japanese people, and a demand to be let into onsens.
This article is also interesting too:https://unseenjapan.com/hajichi-the-banned-traditional-tattoos-of-okinawa/
Many topics we've covered- religion, language, indigenous roots, outside influences- are included in this topic.
As I was reading the replies I was going to ask abut the Uyghurs. I teach about the current situation with the Uyghur population in western China. My students and I discuss how when you remove the modern boundaries the Uyghurs aren't an oddity in that geographic region. Was that a region that was conquored under the Qing? I'll definetly check out that link!
The Manchus moved to incorporate Central Asia into their Qing empire in the 17-18th centuries. The best book on this effort is Peter Perdue's China Marches West. National boundaries have divided some ethnic groups, imposing restrictions on peoples who frequently traded and traveled across the region.
Something this session made me think about was the emphasis on SEL - social-emotional learning in our schools, especially in response to the trauma and isolation students have experienced as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. I know that one buddhist practice is meditation. Many teachers engage their students in some sort of meditation/mindfulness -- I know I do! I imagine there might be some ways to introduce concepts about religions of east asia as we teach our kids about meditation and where it comes from. Of course the way we practice mediation and mindfulness in elementary schools is very different from how its practiced by actual buddhists and it's very much disconnected from the history of organized religion in east asia but I wonder if sharing some images of meditation, some buddhist texts about mindfulness etc. to root our social-emotional learning in the cultural and religious practices of people throughout time and around the world!
Hannah's right about looking at philosophies and religions can help students become more reflective about themselves, their own lives and communities. Sometimes learning about the values of other people and places can help us become more clear about what matters to us and why. It can help sharpen our own priorities and aims. Most kids and most of us most of the time careen from one task or activity to another without fully thinking about why we do what we do, why it matters - or what we might choose to do that is different. Becoming more deliberate in one's choices is hard, but it might be a step to finding greater satisfaction and fulfillment. Thanks to all of you for choosing to be educators and choosing to spend time learning a bit more about East Asia. I hope you think you made the right choice!
I noticed that we didn’t really discuss Shintoism. I think the continuity of Shintoism in Japan combined with the evolution of Zen Buddhism and Neo-Confucianism is super interesting; how they have all three intertwined in Japanese history. Having visited Japan now it is very visibly apparent that Buddhism and Shintoism coexist, some people consider themselves followers of both. There are Buddhist temples with Shinto shrines on the temple grounds like Asakusa in Tokyo. Walking through neighborhoods, we found small Shinto shrines, that had protectorate shrines for that neighborhood. Culturally I think it is fascinating that these things have continued and still play a role in peoples’ lives. Are there any other places in the world where such things are like that? I’m wracking my brain trying to think of comparable examples…the only thing I can think of are some Native American tribes who still maintain traditions but then might also consider themselves Christian but not having really studied that I’m not sure that would be a coexisting example.
Then politically, the emperor, a descendent of the Shinto deity Amaterasu. I know Hirohito had to give up his claim of divinity after WWII and I’m sure the Japanese people don’t really look at Emperor Nurohito and think he is divine. Today the royal family kind of has a similar role to the British royal family. It is still impressive to have a dynastic line that old. Is Japan as attached to the royal family as some Brits are? (excluding the Scots…)
How do other teachers teach about World Religions? Especially some of the ethnic religions?
I loved this article from The Met about the similarities between these sculptures of the Virgin Mary and Guanyin. This would make another great prompt for discussion during a designated ELD session! We could ask students to compare and contrast these two images, perhaps even lifting some text from the article (or modifying it for their reading level). Students could practice gaining the floor, rephrasing, respectfully disagreeing and building on classmates' contributions (connected to both ELD and listening/speaking standards). Seems like the Met's website could be a great resource for integrating east asian history in general!
I watched the speech on Youtube and understand how Muslim issues in Xinjiang nowadays. Machus were good at conquering areas around China, and Xinjiang is such a challenging issue because of religion and ethnicity. Chinese are much afraid of violence, so creating a safe public space is the priority issue. After watching the lecture on Youtube, I searched for what happened in Tiananmen Square in the year 2013. It was such an awful terrorist attack, but I didn't know until I watched the lecture today. I don't know if any other way is better than re-education to prevent the terrorist. In my opinion, this is a helpful way to save lives and prevent more violent accidents in the future.