Viewing 4 posts - 16 through 19 (of 19 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #46614

    As part of a Holocaust unit, we look at other examples of ethnic persecution.  Two that particularly intrigue my students are the Rwandan Genoicide and the Chinese genocide against the Uyghurs.  (When we discuss Rwanda they focus on how seemingly minor differences were exploited by the Belgians to control the area, and how they can't tell the difference between Hutus and Tutsis.  They compare this to the idea of "knowing" someone was Jewish. When we discuss China they fixate on how China denies that genocide is happening.  

    articles we use

    China https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-59595952

    China https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/12/9/china-guilty-of-uighur-genocide-beyond-reasonable-doubt-report

    Rwanda: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-26875506

     

    #46653
    Kayla Kolean
    Spectator

    Thank you for your summary and reading suggestions. 

    I agree that I learned so much from Prof. Kamei's lecture. And that is what is was, a lecture. There is not really room for debate during the presentation, but rather save the discussion for the Question and Answer time. This is common curtousy. 

    I agree that I learned so much from Prof. Kamei's lecture. And that is what is was, a lecture. There is not really room for debate during the presentation, but rather save the discussion for the Question and Answer time. This is common courtesy. 

    I really appreciated the primary sources and first-hand accounts she has collected of this event. It is so important to present multiple views on a topic like this to see how complex the issue was.

    I think that fear has a strong hold on the views of people. Fear from non-Asian citizens that “others” could be spies during this time of war. Fear from the Asian citizens that they might be attacked by the government or be sent back to a country they fled or have no knowledge of. Fear of the government to how the war will progress and turn out. Fear drives so many of these actions.

    I wonder if various perspectives that have emerged in America to Covid-19 Pandemic will be taught through the lenses of fear. Fear for the health of oneself and whatever steps they might take to keep themselves safe (isolation, quarantine, vaccines, masks). Fear for the loss of “normal life” that drives people to dismiss the pandemic as propaganda or something not very serious. I assumed that many educators had thought that the camps for Japanese-Americans was a bad act, but it seems I was wrong as we did have a voice of opposition. I wonder in 10-20 years with more information, we will still have opposing views on correct actions to take in a pandemic.

    Kayla Kolean

     

    #46659
    Betsy Ures
    Spectator

    As a follow-up, I have checked out the book by Ansel Adams titled: "Born Free and Equal". It is really clear that the US attempted to cover up the camp after its closure, but Ansel Adams was able to capture images of Manzanar and the experience of wrongful incarceration. 

    #46661
    Betsy Ures
    Spectator

    Thank you Todd for reminding me of this quote! Elementary students would absolutely be able to engage with it along the topic of wrongful incarceration during WW2.

Viewing 4 posts - 16 through 19 (of 19 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.