Home › Forums › Teaching About Asia Forums › Asia in My Classroom › Japanese Diet and the Story of the Fish Market
I was watching a special on the Travel Channel where they went to Japan to take an in depth look at the Japanese Fish Market. They started at the beginning of it all by looking at all the ways the Japanese catch their fish. Because the Japanese eat 7x more fish than we do in the US they have to supply a lot of fish!
Fish Market Workers getting ready for a busy morning
" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">http://www.nksd.net/schools/sles/japan/images/FishBid.jpg
The Fish Auction - would you pay 10,000 US for one fish?
" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">http://www.nksd.net/schools/sles/japan/images/TunaBidlrg.jpg
In the Restaurant - Take your pic
" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">http://www.bradknapp.com/blog/archives/images/sushi_chef.jpg
On your Plate - Delicious!!
" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">http://www.sfusd.k12.ca.us/schwww/sch618/japan/Food/sashimi.jpg [Edit by="oiwuagwu on Feb 10, 10:19:32 AM"][/Edit]
Very neat pictures. Did the show mention at all how they select the fish, particulary for sushi? I wonder how they keep it fresh and how they know what is ok to eat raw.
They select the fish by the texture of the meat, size, and a few other things. I saw the vendors cutting small chunks off of the fish and then rolling it in thier fingers.
The market is an amazing place. Our teachers' tour visited in 2003 and we'll go back there this summer. You can see a couple of photos from that stop in the trip slideshow:
http://www.international.ucla.edu/asia/slideshows/viewshow.asp?section_ID=126&slideID=43
Tim and Caryn Kelly were on the trip with us in 2003 and have created a useful website which includes a link to a video of the fish market. Please go to http://mrkellysclass.net/Japan/index.html.
Very interesting and colorful photos!
I liked your pictures of the fish market in Japan.
I have found the fish market in Baton Rouge, Louisiana more interesting. There , you pick your fish live, directly out of a huge tub. They will catch it, clean it and hand it to you. You cannot have it any fresher!!
I'm sure similar "live fish markets" exist in other places. I wouldn't know where.
The best place to get a live fish in LA is at a good chinese restaurant. As for Japanese raw fish, just about anything goes as long as it is fresh. Eels, fish eggs, intestines, and fish meat are all good if fresh i.e. no smell! I am a fisherman and have eaten alot of the fish I catch raw. I like halibut and yellowtail the best. After it's cooked it loses some of it nutriments and can taste better or worse depending on the cook and the seasonings. Health experts say anything eaten raw has more food value but you better be sure it's fresh first.
I spent a summer back in the 80's catching giant blue fin tuna (1,000 lbs.) and it was quite a thrill on a hand line. It was also profitable because the Japanese were buying the fish for thousands of dollars and putting them on ice and flying them to Japan to be fresh for market. I'm attaching a couple of pictures of the type of fishing we did and of one of the 4 fish my boat caught. If you ever want to go fishing locally, let me know.
My 1,000 lb. story is not just a "fish story". The pictures weren't attached the first time so here they are to prove it.
Did anyone know how the style of the sushi-bar started? Yeah!! It was exactly how you have described at the Tsukiji Fish Market. Fisherman and market people were too busy to eat their lunch at the restaurant or take their lunch to the park or anything like that. So, what they did was just slice some of the fresh fish and put them on top of the cooked rice and dip a bit of it in soy sauce. Their lunch time was at the bar in the matter of 5 minutes (not even seated). They ate some ginger at the end to rinse out the fishy taste from their mouth. Well, the style of the sushi bar became some kind of fad that now, we pay some fortune to sit at the bar to eat uncooked fish. Like ten years ago, there were no such thing as ....roll, and ....roll. Japanese people didn't even know what in the world "California Roll" was then. Many Japanese who visit sushi bar here in U.S. love different kind of rolls, but they pretend not. Their sushi pride won't permit them to admit liking imported new wave sushi from U.S.[Edit by="spadilla on Jun 3, 7:37:36 PM"][/Edit]
This is a great topic and one that will ensnare students. Tsukiji, Tokyo's famed fish market, is examined in a terrific book about the place of fish and this market in Japanese history and culture:
Theodore C. Bestor, _Tsukiji: The Fish Market at the Center of the World_
California Studies in Food and Culture, 11, A Philip E. Lilienthal Book in Asian Studies
Published July 2004 by UC Press. It's currently on sale for $15. Go to
http://www.ucpress.edu/books/sale/pages/8737.html
It's a 400+ page book. Chapter 3 is available for download -- click on the icon below.
If you ever have a chance to go to Japan, try some fresh fish at "Katsugyo (live fish)" restaurant. There are many of those in the big city in Japan. They serve fish like Japanese mackerel or large shrimp live, and you eat it while it's alive. The chef will catch a swimming fish from the tank, slice it up real quick and chop it up, and heap it on its back bone with some chopped onion and ground ginger on a fancy ceramic dish. You would indulge while its tail is still moving. Sounded greatly delicious when I was living in Japan, but not since I have been away from that kind of environment for a while. How cruel, disgusting and inhumane!! I used to feel lucky to be able to enjoy such a meal. Now, I feel like a big sinner. And...you can share my sinful experience.
Those were some great fish photos and facts! I will definitely be able to use them not only in my history classes when discussing various cultural elements of Japan but also in my Life Management classes when we talk about food around the world, nutrition and protein. Thanks again!
I remember this one special where there was a very large fish and fish buyers were bidding in the thousands for it.
One of the best ways to relate the largess of the Japanese seafood diet is to relate to the students the parallels we see in America regarding meat and poultry products. If you have ever see a slaughterhouse to market place process in the American food industry, you see the same passion and cultural richness near our doorsteps. I always wanted to see a live Texas cattle option, and the Tuna auction parallels that in a more intimate circle (fishermen in fish slime smocks, sushi buyers with huge wads of cash [quarter million+ on hand] and gawking tourist trying to make sense). If you just see the variety, and me as a fish lover, and the size and prices, you cannot be near seafood heaven.
While sushi/sashimi lovers would love to eat on the spot, the surrounding blocks offer fresh sushi restaurants opening around 6AM! The decision you have to make is, can I really eat all this fish this early in the morning...After all, it is dinnertime back in the USA.... But if you don't like fish, the "brunch" that locals are eating up to 10AM is actually lunch/dinner for many workers offer a variety of dishes nearby such as rice bowls, noodles, and even curry. My really personal inner pain began to grow on my last visit, when I realized on my last day in Japan, I could not take any of the fresh fish home.... Damn the agricultural inspections.... I remember as a kid, my grandmother visiting me here in LA brought illegal contraband of salmon eggs once... Thank you grandma... To me, this stuff beats Russian caviar any day...
The Tsukiji market is a must see for Tokyo visitors but make sure you wake up early and keep your sense about. First, its early morning. Are you really fully alert and awake??? If not, the fish smells and the lively activity at the market will... I not talking about that rotting seafood smell we often get at not so great seafood departments in American supermarkets... I'm talking about literally tons of fresh seafood in your face. Some rare foods may delight, or for the weak of stomach, scare your appetites. Don't forget to wear waterproof, no fancy shoes. The warehouse floor is covered with ice, water, and fish juice. The walkways are very narrow, but if you stay out of the big-time fish buyers, most stalls are accommodating for pictures and sometimes minor purchases such as dried goods. Lastly, be careful around the non-stop traffic inside the market zone. There are moving scooters, trucks, and hand dollies everywhere, even in the narrow aisles. What got to me was the exhaust fumes in some areas of the dock warehouse areas... The great thing about 6AM travel in the Tsukiji area is that it is not a busy time of day for most of Tokyo, at least not until the morning commute. If you are stuck in fully loaded trains in the morning, you are probably too late for most the activities at the market.
The market, especially the fish market, is a fascinating space to explore. I was recently in Seattle and had the chance to watch men yell and throw odd looking creatures of the sea over the heads of odd looking tourists from various parts of America. I have also had the privilege of experiencing the chaos of the San Pedro market and the mayhem of the San Francisco market. I can only begin to imagine the wild frenzy of the Japanese fish market.
Now Japanese have always been critical of our American diets and I feel they have the right to do so. We are a nation detached from our food source. How many Americans can visit and buy from a fresh fish market even if they wanted to? I don’t know! Can one do this in Oklahoma? Or even Fontana? Of course there are lakes and streams throughout our country and we need not rely on ocean alone but those are far too.
I watched a Japanese man once fishing off the pier. He caught a fish, filleted it and ate it right there in front of me. It was beautiful. There is a camaraderie that is established in a fish market. Community is developed. Social strata are defined. Numerous people exploring sundry delicacies of the sea, all edible, together in oceanic harmony.
I can’t imagine experiencing the same thing in a butcher shop.