Home › Forums › Summer Institutes › Crossing Boundaries in East Asia, Summer 2020 › Session 2 (July 30) - Lori Meeks, USC
Hi Marina,
I think you are correct. I still want to find out more information about this, but I am really happy that Professor Meeks gave us more information than I have gotten before, even when talking to people from China, Cambodia etc, or traveling in India, Thailand etc.
Spacibah (One of the few Russian words I remember, but I do not have the Cyrillac keyboard)!
Wow Marina,
I envy your experience going on that trip through Yale especially. I agree with Joseph that you must have quite a unique experience as you approach various parts of this seminar. I have not been very successful with meditation in the past, but I did register for a session, so at least I am sure it will be interesting. Thanks for the link and the info!
Hi Cheryl, one thing I like about being in this seminar is not only learning so much, but seeing other people's ideas, and thining of ways I can incorporate them into my own lessons. I have discussed Christian televangelists (and lavish lifestyles) in my classes, but I have never thought about Buddhists in that way, although I am aware of a scandal a few years ago among Buddhists living posh lifestyles and even a whole organized gang "war" in Korea a couple of decades ago in which monks were involved. Thanks for giving me other ideas to make this more exciting and relatable for my students, since Buddhism is probably the most "foreign" of the major religions that I teach , given my student population.
Page 46. Each nation has its own myth of the arrival of Buddhism. In the case of China, it is said that the emperor Ming of the Han Dynasty (who reigned from 58c.e. to 75c.e.) had a dream in which he saw a golden spirit outside of his palace, emitting rays of light from the top of his head. When he told his ministers about his dream, they reported that they have heard about the sage called "Buddha" who was able to fly. The emperor dispatched a party of envoys, who journeyed westward into Central Asia and the eastern end of the vast and vague region that the Greeks called "Scythia", returning with a copy of the Scripture in Forty-two Sections (p. 496).
In Tibet, the king received a Chinese princess in a marriage as part of the treaty between the nations.
The Russian Primary Chronicle reports that in the year 987, Vladimir the Great (Vladimir the Red Sun) sent envoys to study the religions of the various neighboring nations: Islam, Judaism, The Latin Church and Eastern Christionanity, and his emissaries came with detailed reports. In Constantinople (Tsargrad is a Slavic name for the city of Constantinople, the capital of the Eastern Roman Empire, and present-day Istanbul in Turkey) they reported: "We no longer knew whether we were in heaven or on earth", describing a majestic Divine Liturgy in the Byzantine Church Hagia Sophia "nor such beauty, and we know not how to tell of it." Ultimately Vladimir chose to adapt Eastern Christianity and married the Byzantine emperor Basil II's sister Anna. Returning to Kiev in triumph, Vladimir exhorted the residents of his capital to the Dnieper river for baptism. This mass baptism became the iconic inaugural event in the Christianization of the state of Kievan Rus. Every year on July 28 Russia celebrates The Day of Baptism of Russia.
After listening to the lectures and readings I became interested in examining the Buddhist monastic vows of poperty (and begging) and asceticism, and how the Buddhism adjusted to the culture and traditions of India and China. I am very familiar with Russian Orthodoxy and I am planning to use more examples and "compare and contract" excersises from Buddhist tradition to illustrate my point in my classroom.
Begging appeared more openly in Russia soon after the dismantlement of the Soviet regime. The post-Soviet transformations also encouraged a particularly vivid revival of Russian Orthodoxy. Old churches were restored and reopened; new ones were erected. The surroundings of the Orthodox churches are nowadays typical places for begging. Church almsgiving has become again one of the most ordinary expressions of Orthodox compassion in post-Soviet Russia.
The Holy Fool or The Blessed Fool for the Sake of God is the Russian version of foolishness for Christ, a peculiar form of Eastern Orthodox asceticism.
It was extensively adopted in Muscovite Russia in the 14th century.
Some characteristics that were commonly seen in holy fools were going around half-naked weighed themselves down with chains, being homeless, prayed throughout the whole night, received food only from poor people, speaking in riddles, being believed to be clairvoyant and a prophet, and occasionally being disruptive and challenging, though always to make a point. He (or she) was believed to have been divinely inspired, and was therefore able to say truths event to the Tsars which others could not, normally in the form of indirect allusions or parables. He had a particular status in regard to the Tsars, as a figure not subject to earthly control or judgement. There are a number of references to the Holy Folls in 19th century Russian literature by A.S. Pushkin, F.M. Dostoevsky, L.N. Tolstoy.
Everybody knows the St. Basil Cathedral in Moscow. Russia, but not everybody knows about St. Basil or St. Basil The Blessed.
Basil the Blessed (known also as Basil, fool for Christ; Basil, Wonderworker of Moscow; or Blessed Basil of Moscow, fool for Christ) is a Russian Orthodox Saint of the type known as "holy fool for Christ".
The Cathedral of Vasily the Blessed, commonly known as Saint Basil's Cathedral, is a Christian church in Red Square in Moscow, Russia and is regarded as a cultural symbol of the country. The building, now a museum, is officially known as the Cathedral of the Intercession of the Most Holy Theotokos on the Moat. It was built from 1555 to 1561 on orders from Ivan the Terrible and commemorates the captute of Khanate of Kazan and Astrakhan Khanate. It was the city's tallest building until 1600. The building contained eight churches arranged around a ninth, central church of Intercession, a tenth church was erected in 1588 over the grave of a specially venerated local Moscow saint Vasily (Basil), (Basil died on August 2, 1552 and St. Macarius, Metropolitan of Moscow, served his funeral with many clergy) and soon the Cathedral became known as St. Basil's Cathedral. Basil was formally canonised in 1588. His feast day is celebrated today, on August 2.
Page 46. Each nation has its own myth of the arrival of Buddhism. In the case of China, it is said that the emperor Ming of the Han Dynasty (who reigned from 58c.e. to 75c.e.) had a dream in which he saw a golden spirit outside of his palace, emitting rays of light from the top of his head. When he told his ministers about his dream, they reported that they have heard about the sage called "Buddha" who was able to fly. The emperor dispatched a party of envoys, who journeyed westward into Central Asia and the eastern end of the vast and vague region that the Greeks called "Scythia", returning with a copy of the Scripture in Forty-two Sections (p. 496).
Constantine I was a Roman emperor who ruled early in the 4th century. In 312, Constantine I fought in Italy. Accounts of Constantine's life state that, following a vision, he had ordered a Christian symbol to be painted on his soldiers' shields. Under this emblem, Constantine was successful in battle and entered Rome. He soon used his power to address the status of Christians, issuing the Edict of Milan in 313 that protected Christians in the empire. This proclamation legalized Christianity and allowed for freedom of worship throughout the empire. In 324, Constantine I became a Roman emperor. After this triumph, Constantine founded the city of Constantinople on the site of Byzantium. Constantine Constantine was also the first emperor to adhere to Christianity. He was the first Christian emperor and saw the empire begin to become a Christian state. He converted to Christianity on his deathbed in 337.
"Scythia", Scythian Gold, Hermitage Museum, Faberge
After having completed the readings I became interested in examining the religious beliefs of Scythians and their connections to Buddhism. Why did the envoy find a copy of the Scripture in Forty-two Sections in "Scythia"?
Page 46. Each nation has its own myth of the arrival of Buddhism. In the case of China, it is said that the emperor Ming of the Han Dynasty (who reigned from 58c.e. to 75c.e.) had a dream in which he saw a golden spirit outside of his palace, emitting rays of light from the top of his head. When he told his ministers about his dream, they reported that they have heard about the sage called "Buddha" who was able to fly. The emperor dispatched a party of envoys, who journeyed westward into Central Asia and the eastern end of the vast and vague region that the Greeks called "Scythia", returning with a copy of the Scripture in Forty-two Sections (p. 496).
I am very familiar with the unique collection of the Scythian gold from the Hermitage Museum in St. Petersburg, Russia. The most valuable artefacts were produced by the nomadic tribes of the area known as Scythia from the 7th to 3rd centuries BC. The identities of the nomadic peoples of the steppes is often uncertain, and the term "Scythian" should often be taken loosely; the art of nomads much further east than the core Scythian territory exhibits close similarities as well as differences, and terms such as the "Scytho-Siberian world" are often used.
The major contribution for the collection of the Scythian gold, started by Peter the Great in early 18c and continued by Catherine the Great who ordered a systematic study be made of the works, was made during the time of Russian Emperor Alexander III with the development of modern archaeological techniques and efforts of the Russian archaeologists specializing in Central Asia who led many of the most important excavations of kurgans. Russian scholars from the State Hermitage Museum have concluded that a discovery of Scythian gold in a Siberian grave in summer of 2001 is the earliest of its kind ever found and that it predates Greek influence. The find is leading to a change in how scholars view the Scythians, supposed barbaric, nomadic tribes that once roamed the Eurasian steppes. (See the article in its original context in New York Times from January 9, 2002, Section E, Page 1)
In 1882 Fabergé won a gold medal at the Pan-Russian Exhibition in Moscow, where he attracted the attention of the Tsar, Alexander III (1845-94), and his wife, Marie Feodorovna (1847-1928). Tsar Alexander III personally praised Faberge for his replica of a gold Scythian bracelet from the 4th century BC. Three years later, in 1885, Faberge was awarded a warrant as official supplier to the imperial court. It was then that the Tsar commissioned Fabergé to produce the first Imperial Easter Egg for his wife Maria, starting an annual tradition which would showcase some of his most inventive and sophisticated craftsmanship.
After having completed the readings I became interested in examining the religious beliefs of Scythians and their connections to Buddhism. Why did the envoy find a copy of the Scripture in Forty-two Sections in "Scythia"?
Page 46. Each nation has its own myth of the arrival of Buddhism. In the case of China, it is said that the emperor Ming of the Han Dynasty (who reigned from 58c.e. to 75c.e.) had a dream in which he saw a golden spirit outside of his palace, emitting rays of light from the top of his head. When he told his ministers about his dream, they reported that they have heard about the sage called "Buddha" who was able to fly. The emperor dispatched a party of envoys, who journeyed westward into Central Asia and the eastern end of the vast and vague region that the Greeks called "Scythia", returning with a copy of the Scripture in Forty-two Sections (p. 496).
I am very familiar with the unique collection of the Scythian gold from the Hermitage Museum in St. Petersburg, Russia. The most valuable artefacts were produced by the nomadic tribes of the area known as Scythia from the 7th to 3rd centuries BC. The identities of the nomadic peoples of the steppes is often uncertain, and the term "Scythian" should often be taken loosely; the art of nomads much further east than the core Scythian territory exhibits close similarities as well as differences, and terms such as the "Scytho-Siberian world" are often used.
The major contribution for the collection of the Scythian gold, started by Peter the Great in early 18c and continued by Catherine the Great who ordered a systematic study be made of the works, was made during the time of Russian Emperor Alexander III with the development of modern archaeological techniques and efforts of the Russian archaeologists specializing in Central Asia who led many of the most important excavations of kurgans. Russian scholars from the State Hermitage Museum have concluded that a discovery of Scythian gold in a Siberian grave in summer of 2001 is the earliest of its kind ever found and that it predates Greek influence. The find is leading to a change in how scholars view the Scythians, supposed barbaric, nomadic tribes that once roamed the Eurasian steppes. (See the article in its original context in New York Times from January 9, 2002, Section E, Page 1)
In 1882 Fabergé won a gold medal at the Pan-Russian Exhibition in Moscow, where he attracted the attention of the Tsar, Alexander III (1845-94), and his wife, Marie Feodorovna (1847-1928). Tsar Alexander III personally praised Faberge for his replica of a gold Scythian bracelet from the 4th century BC. Three years later, in 1885, Faberge was awarded a warrant as official supplier to the imperial court. It was then that the Tsar commissioned Fabergé to produce the first Imperial Easter Egg for his wife Maria, starting an annual tradition which would showcase some of his most inventive and sophisticated craftsmanship.
Thank you for the resources Jiaxing Weng-Zhang, it will be important to include videos, cartoons, and age appropriate movies for students of all ages. However, students will probably mock the earlier attempts at special effects in movies earlier than 2000.
Fourteen Questions about which Buddha Remained Silent and Why
I found one link to a short article about the Fourteen Questions about which Buddha Remained Silent and Why.
It covers the questions from a few of the Buddhist schools of thought.
This is first time to learn I grew up in the "Buddhism-Taoism-Confucius" environment in Taiwna, but actually I was not aware before. Professor Meeks' methodology opended up a new perpsective to me. Truly enjoyed the class and saw all the classmates' discussion. Much appreciated.
Tom- I would have no problem with you sharing my experiences. I have a lot of pictures from the Thai temples if you would be interested in any of those too. The Reclining Buddha statue is mind-blowing. My students have a super skewed view of Islam as well, even when we've had Muslim students, that were from Yemen move to my school. I don't always spend a lot of time on world religions in my class; it varies from semester to semester, because art is so broad, but I have probably spent more time on Islam, trying to dispel the stereotypes and tell the story of some of the artists and their culture. I want to spend more time on Buddhist and Hindu art, and I think that music video is beautiful and I saved it to share in my class as well. Thanks.
One of the things that has always intrigued me about the religions of Japan has been the coexistence of Shintoism and Buddhism. Just walking around Japan will give you insight into how the two belief systems have incorporated themselves into the fabric of society without obvious/overt conflict between the two. You could be walking around an ancient village like Asuka Village and see numerous Buddhism temples adjacent to Shinto shrines, speaking to Professor Meek's integration of Buddhism with traditional kami cults and how it was vitally important to the success and spread of Buddhism in Japan. In modern Japan, during the new year celebrations, Japanese society engages in the traditional hastumode (first Shinto shrine visit of the year). In this practice, the Japanese discard the previous year's Shinto amulet and get a new one for the new year to bring new fortunes. Buddhism, on the other hand, is more concerned on the soul of the afterlife; this is why most Japanese families will honor the death of a family member in a Buddhist service at a temple. Below are a couple of other readings I found that might be of interest to some.
https://www.japantimes.co.jp/culture/2013/05/16/arts/seeing-where-shinto-and-buddhism-cross/
https://nirc.nanzan-u.ac.jp/nfile/3344
https://japanology.org/2016/06/buddhism-and-shinto-the-two-pillars-of-japanese-culture/
Mark- That's interesting to know about Myanmar. Since we visited several different temples in Bangkok and in other parts as we travelled, it was interesting to note, that some times we could wear shorts and tank tops, sometimes, a t-shirt with a long skirt was appropriate, we took our shoes off inside of temples and climbing up the stairs that increased in depth, outside in a long skirt, was not the easiest thing. Our professor was very adamant about us understanding the culture we were going into and what was appropriate and what wasn't and I wish that more people travelling would do that, so as not to disrespect local architecture and art and belief systems.
Your post raises some really great points and ideas. The question that you are planning to pose to your students, "Can someone observe two religions at one time?" is a great way to start a lesson not only about Buddhism, but any belief system. However, like you point out, Buddhism ideaology is in-line with other mainstream belief systems that it isn't difficult to "feel connected," like you write. Although the classification of Buddhism as non-theistic is not one that I have much knowledge about, I think that it would be a great research topic for older-aged students!
Maria,
These articles are awesome. It can be so hard to include female voices in pre-Modern history so I really appreciate these resources. I too was really struck by the idea that one of the charcteristics of Buddhism that appealed to the Chinese was that it provided an opportunity to provide support and appreciatio for mothers in a way that was not possible under Confucian systems.